Abstract
Isolation methods that employ readily-available inexpensive supplies on the open market, which are reliable, as well as economical, such as nucleic acid amplification techniques (NAAT) based on microfluidic technology in low-resource research settings (LRRS) that meets the ASSURED guidelines are essential to develop a noninvasive diagnostic colon cancer screen in stool using micro(mi)RNA molecules. A combination of a microfluidic-based MiRNA stool test with a reliable rolling circle amplification/detection method applied to the quantification of miRNA molecules, result in an affordable sensitive and specific isothermal method for the noninvasive quantitative detection of miRNAs in LRRS.
Scientists and engineers have become interested in miRNAs, and they have intensified their efforts to apply emerging simple detection tools to the important bioanalytical challenge of quantifying these small 18-26 nt long molecules. Some of the proposed approaches incorporate novel material, such as simple centrifuges and methods based on microfluidic technology, while others utilize the interesting biological properties of these molecules, such as forming branched RCA structures, allowing for the detection of these biomarker molecules at an attomolar "aM" concentration level, using low cost extraction and isothermal amplification methods in LRRS.
We have been interested in studying colorectal cancer (CRC) because it is the 3rd most common malignancy worldwide, and stool can be obtained noninvasively from the patients. We have focused in this research on colon cancer (CC) because it is more common in the USA than rectal cancer (RC). The innovation of our approach lies in the exploratory use of an affordable, quantitative miRNA profiling in noninvasive stool samples in LRRS, whose extracted fragile total RNA is stabilized shortly after excretion from stool by commercially available kits, so it does not ever fragment, followed by quantitative standardized analytical tests that are neither labor intensive, nor require expensive instrumentation, in order to develop apanel of novel miRNA genes for the noninvasive diagnostic screening of early left and right sporadic colon cancers, more economically, and with higher sensitivity and specificity than any other colon cancer screening test currently available on the market.
To show the clinical sensitivity and specificity of the proposed quantitative miRNA test using simple methodologies in LRRS,the miRNA results are to be correlated with FOBT, colonoscopy, and pathology data. Standardization establishes test s performance criteria (sample selection, optimal sample running conditions, preservation and storage), in order to ensure that the assay will perform the same way in any laboratory, by any trained personnel, anywhere in low-resource laboratory settings worldwide
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2020
E. Ahmed Farid, et al.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Introduction
Nucleic acid amplification techniques (NAAT) are becoming an increasingly important part of clinicians’ tool box. Nucleic acid detection today has mainly been confined thus far to wealthy, developed countries or to large centralized facilities in the developing world that can afford resources required to carry out these methods. Economic and infrastructural realities dictate that diagnostics for the low-resource settings (LRS) need to be affordable, sensitive, specific, user-friendly, rapid, equipment-free and deliverable to end users (ASSURED) A toe warmer (Heat Factory, Vista, CA) was used as a heat source for a helicase-dependent isothermal amplification (HAD), 65oC±2oC of DNA for 55 min. It consists of a polypropylene bag containing iron, salt, activated carbon, cellulose and vermiculite. When exposed to oxygen in the air, the iron powder oxidizes in an exothermic reaction. The salt serves as a catalyst; the carbon serves to disperse the heat; vermiculite is used as an insulator to maintain the generated heat; and cellulose is a filler. Since the chemical components inside the commercially available toe warmer are fixed, the duration of the reaction as well as the degree of heat generated will mainly depend on air exposure and humidity supply. Relative humidity is important because water on the surface of iron particles can enhance iron oxidation and therefore generate more heat. When this toe warmer is put inside a covered Styrofoam cup that has holes in it, the amount of vapor that interacts with iron particles is dependent on the number of holes on the Styrofoam cup; the more holes, the more vapor can be trapped to react with iron. Thus, by controlling the number of holes in the cup, the temp and duration of the reaction can be manipulated Microfluidic-enabled testing is an option in the development of appropriate, easy-to-adapt diagnostic technologies in LSR. It affords several advantages such as low cost, energy efficiency, capacity to perform complex functions in a single device, lightweight and portability for in-field testing, high sensitivity with small sample volumes and a relatively fast output MicroRNAs are short endogenous noncoding RNAs (16-26 nucleotides) that have been associated with cancer Cloning was one of the first methods used to detect miRNAs Microarrays allowed simultaneous analysis of multiple samples, but lacked sensitivity & specificity Homogenous methods such as RT-qPCR The biomarker discovery approach outlined herein has been designed to test the hypothesis that “ The
Materials And Methods
Collaborating clinicians must be made aware of the constraints imposed by working with RNA, and the need to preserve it so it does not ever fragment after extraction of these short ~20 nucleotide-long molecules from human stool. After consenting prospective individuals when they report to the clinic for consult, those individuals (age 18 to 90 years old) not showing polyps, or inflammatory bowel disease such as colitis or diverticulitis, will be asked by their physicians if they wish to participate in the study. If they agree, they or their guardian will be consented, each given a stool collection kit and detailed oral and written collection instructions. Each study subject will collect one 10 g stool sample, in a standardized fashion, in a large 40 cc plastic jacket prior to any bowel preparation. The study nurse will show and ask participants to obtain samples using a clean plastic spoon from both the mucinous layer, which is rich in colonocytes, and the non-mucinous parts of stool in order to have a representation of the entire colon (both right and left side colon) MiRNA data are to be analyzed by RCA, and using 80% power in a Power Analysis calculation to detect differences in expression between CC stages and control group at a larger standard deviation and a 75% reduction in the difference, to optain adequate group size of control subjects and colon cancer patients from different stages of colon cancer (adenomas, TNM stage 0-I; TNM stage II; and TNM stages III & IV) selected randomly is an adequate number of samples to test. for the purpose of this study. An adequate number of subjects who do not have colon cancer need to be chosed randomly.To avoid bias, and ensure that biomarker selection and outcome assessment does not influence each other, a prospective specimen collection retrospective blinded evaluation (PRoBE) design randomized selection A six aims and a proposed timeline for achieving these aims in a 5 year clinical research study are detailed in 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. RNA isolation procedures (both automatic and manual), compared to those used for isolation of DNA from stool samples Total RNA can be manually isolate from colon laser capture microdissected (LCM) tissue, and from stool by using Qiagen s RNeasy Isolation Kit® (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) containing a RLT buffer (a guanidinium-based solution) according to manufacturer s instructions, getting the advantage of manufacturer s established validation and quality control standards, thereby increasing the probability of good results. Generally, total RNA isolated from stool is suitable for amplification of miRNAs by RCA without the need to further purify mRNA because purified mRNA involves additional steps, and the increased sensitivity could be balanced for by the potential loss of material Isolated RNA in nuclease-free water can be stored at -80oC until needed. It can then be quantified spectrophotometrically at 260 nm. Acquiring sufficient mRNA to analyze from stool or isolated colonocytes is feasible, as each cell contain ~ 20 pg total RNA, and only few nanograms are needed per RCA reaction A total of 50 pmol of forward and reverse oligonucleotides (Invitrogen), according to the sequence of the interrogated miRNA, can be annealed by incubation at 75oC for 5 min, and then slowly cooled to room temperature (~ 30 min). The fill-in reaction to form dsDNA template can be performed in a 20 µl volume containing 10 mM Tris-HCl, 50 mM NaCl, 10 mM MgCl2, 1 mM DTT, 0.25 mM dNTPs and 5U Klenow Fragment (3 - 5 exo) New England Biolabs at 37oC for 1 h. Then the reaction mixture can heated at 75oC for 20 min to inactivate the enzyme, and slowly cooled to room temperature for dscDNA annealing (see A total of 20 µl of the above dsDNA template mixture can be added into 30 µl of Before miRNA is reverse transcribed, the RT primer is to be chemically phosphorylated at the 5 end by heating a 0.5 nmol RT primer to 75oC for 5 min, then chilling on ice prior to treatment with kinase. The 50 µl reaction volume containing 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.0), 10 mM MgCl2, 5 mM DTT, 2 mM DTT, 1 mM ATP, 20 U T4 polynucleotide kinase and DNA probe formation can be carried out at 37oC for 2 h, followed by inactivation of the T4 polynucleotide kinase at 65oC for 20 min. RT reaction for formation of cDNA from miRNA can be carried out in a 10 µl reaction volume that contains 1µl of total RNA sample, 500 nM 5 -phosphorylated RT primers, 20 U MultiScribeO RT (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) , 50 µM dNTPs and 1X reaction buffer (pH 8.3, 50 mM Tris-HCl, 75 mM KCl and 3 mM MgCl2), followed by the addition of 2.5 U Ribonuclease H at 37oC for 20 min for the degradation of miRNA strand in the RNA-DNA hybrid. These steps can be followed up by probe ligation and rolling circle amplification (see Jonstrup For extraction of genomic DNA from stool in a LRS, a manual extraction for stool samples that employs a QIAamp DNA Stool Mini Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA), can be used. A fast, convenient method for label-free detection of amplified markers, which can be routinely carried out, using genomic DNA isolated from stool colonocytes by the DNA Extraction Kit (Qiagen), on 6 of the 10 Bethesda markers recommended by NCI Modifying the genomic DNA before non-PCR amplification by sodium metabisulfite treatment If the difference in miRNA gene expression between healthy and cancer patients and among the stages of cancer at the end of the study is as large and as informative for multiple miRNA genes, suggesting that classification procedures could be based on values exceeding a threshold, then sophisticated classification would not be needed to distinguish between the two study groups. However, if inconsistent differences on large samples are found, then it is recommended to use predictive classification methods, as detailed below. The goal in predictive classification will be to assign cases to predefined classes based on information collected from the cases. In the simplest setting, the classes (i.e., tumors) are labeled cancerous and non-cancerous. Statistical analyses for predictive classification of the information collected (i.e., microarrays and qPCR on miRNA genes) attempt to approximate an optimal classifier. Classification can be linear, nonlinear, or nonparametric False positive discovery rates (expected portion of incorrect assignment among the expected assignments) can also be assessed by statistical methods For the corrected index, cross-validation Power analysis can be implemented for estimating sample size in such a study Principal component analysis (PCA) If by the end of the study, the miRNA gene panel (or a derived PMI) is better than existing screening methods, all of the data generated can be used to assess the model so over-fitting is not a concern. The level of gene expression can be displayed in a database using parallel coordinate plots If results show that individual miRNA genes offer distinct and clear separation between control and cancer, there will be not need to derive a predictive miRNA index (PMI) % Sensitivity = TP x 100 TP + FN % Specificity = TN x 100 FP + TN Above methods represent the most practical, least labor-intensive and economical approach to accomplish research aims. However, in few problematic samples (<5%) in control, or pre-malignant or malignant cases, it may be necessary to use other methods. However, because the error rate is so small and would occur in control and cases, adopting different extraction/analyses methods will not bias results. In very few samples, inhibitors present in stool may make it difficult to isolate RNA using Qiagen kits that provide the advantage of manufacturer's established validation and QC standards. In such cases, RNA can be manually isolated by a modification of the classical acid guanidinium thiocyanate-phenol-chloroform (AGPC) method Signosis, Inc., Sunnyvale, CA (www.signosisinc.com) introduced high throughput plate assay for monitoring individual miRNAs, without the need to carry out a RT reaction. In that assay one of the bridge oligos partially hybridizes with the miRNA molecule and the capture oligo, and another bridge forms a hybrid between the miRNA molecule and the detection oligo. The hybrid that is sensitive to the miRNA sequence is immobilized onto a plate and detected by a streptavidin-horse radish peroxidase conjugate and chemiluminescent substrate using a plate reader. One oligonucleotide difference prevents hybrid formation; thus miRNA isoform could be differentiated. MiRNAs are resistant to ribonucleases present in stool, probably by inclusion in lipid or lipoprotein complexes
Method-Aim/Months
Aim 1:Standardize sample acquisition,processing and handling & epidem- iologically selectstudy population
Aim 2: Standardize total RNA extraction by QA methods & perform RCAs to study miRNAs gene expression at various CC stages
Aim 3: Employ epigenetics to study genetic heterogeneity by identifying MSS-MSI phenotypes & investigate promoter methylation in CC stages
Aim 4: Finalize accessing test performance characteristics & numerical under-pinning of the proposed RCA approach for CC
Aim 5: Use statistical methods for data analyses
Aim 6: Provide & carry out alternate standardized methods to achieve study goals, if needed
1-4
·········a
·
5-8
········
·
·
9-12
······
··
·
··
·
13-16
·········
·
17-20
·· ···· ··
·
·
21-24
······
··
·
··
·
25-28
·········
·
29-32
········
·
·
33-36
······
··
·
··
·
37-40
·········a
·
41-44
········
·
·
45-48
······
··
·
··
·
49-52
·········
·
53-57
·· ···· ··
·
·
57-60
······
··
·
··
·
Cancer Cases
Tue Positive (TP)
False Negative (FN)
Normal Subjects
False Positive (FP)
True Negative (TN)